Now - please don't just list a server or game off the bat. I want to know what features in particular make a game AMAZING. Do you like colorful or dull graphics? Detailed or cartoony? Cute or creepy or outrageous or scary? Do you like multiplayer or singleplayer? Sandbox games or ones with storylines? Roleplaying games? Games where you can level up? Do you like games with lots of small updates or lesser big updates? Do you like games where you can go in different levels with different obstacles? Ones with monsters to defeat? Shooting games? Do you like games with puzzles that require brains or games that are simply: do this 50 times. Do you like games that let you customize the look or tiles, texture packs? What about games with deep storyline? Describe the best (and seriously. Dont be like "I LIKE GAMES THAT ARE FULL OF PONIES RIDING LLAMAS") possible game - from graphics to gameplay to the contols and levels, from multiplayer or single to puzzle or adveture or simulation, roleplaying, shooting, comedy.
I want to know this because i want to design games when im older. Who knows, perhaps your idea of a perfect game will be out then!  

TL-DR  

2D Retro Adventure..  

If it's fair I would support any game  

2D games, like Zelda, but with really open storylines, so if you get stuck on something, you can still progress in the game.  

free roam, the ability to do whatever whenever you want, but still a strong story line you would want to follow, the ability to customize your character and make it yours. Examples: Sims or Skyrim  

It needs to be very well-developed. Not some crap that has absolutely no interesting levels and has a purpose for nothing.  

free roam zelda games. like pokemon style without pokemons =D  

Graal with a sotryline and original/thoughtful/colorful graphics and quests.  

My vision of a perfect game is one that has a good story mode that is also made for co-op, online multiplayer, customizable character, unlocks (achievments, armor, clothing, etc.), splitscreen, options, extras, etc. This game would be a first person shooter, but would also feature a third person option for those who prefer that. It would also involve melee weapons such as swords, pipes, etc. There would also be grappling hooks, vehicles, gliders, parachutes, etc. It would take place in cities and would have enter-able buildings that could also be destroyed like in Battlefield 3. There would also be NPC citizens walking around, doing jobs, driving, etc. to make it more realistic. It's hard to describe my perfect game without going into too much detail, but also giving a somewhat clear picture of what I'm looking for.  

Just saying my favorite game i say pfft to rules: Kid Icarus Uprising. the graphics are amazing, multi player mode is intense and fast, and fun, and it doesnt take me 5 days for me to complete a file 100% for a change!  

Posted by Katniss

Now - please don't just list a server or game off the bat

I think you are all (cept Tyler, peter, and elusive kinda) are blind.
This was the first thing i said.
And you all went to list a game.  

Posted by Katniss

I think you are all (cept Tyler, peter, and elusive kinda) are blind.
This was the first thing i said.
And you all went to list a game.

I am blind because I gave an example of what I was describing? okay...  

Actually I love how pokemon is planed. Even though you have played through the game you can still practise them and have some fun. There should be more of such 2D games but more into a Zelda style rather than a pokemon design.
As 3D I think BF is part of the best example. Should be a shooter with a very big and open map where you can actually do everything.  

Posted by callimuc

Actually I love how pokemon is planed. Even though you have played through the game you can still practise them and have some fun. There should be more of such 2D games but more into a Zelda style rather than a pokemon design.
As 3D I think BF is part of the best example. Should be a shooter with a very big and open map where you can actually do everything.

you're going to get called blind because you gave game examples of what you like to back up your description. just a warning <3