Towering rewards should be brought back to revitalize the community as well as get people out of the damn battle arena socializing. It should be different however in the sense that one should not be able to just rotate members out of their guild as they see fit. This creates many people competing to get one reward and feeling bitter if they are not chosen by the leader to receive the reward. In addition it also prevents leaders from giving towering rewards to their friends who may not have worked as hard or even worked for the reward.
My solution to this would be to add a cooldown between kicking and reinviting players to a guild. For example, a player who is kicked canít rejoin the guild for a week or more. Of course, the time could be tweaked and such. To prevent alts abusing this there could be a cooldown between kicking a player and inviting a new one. Especially with guilds now being much larger than they previously were, it makes a non-rotating roster more viable.
In my opinion, this would make towering much less of an aimless pursuit and would remedy the problems many saw with towering rewards.
Let me know what you guys think.
Also milestone rewards like Thallenís thread from way back when stated