wouldn't be very practical for it to operate that way because a core proposed component that makes this whole thing work is that guilds lose points when their members leave or are kicked, so allowing anyone and everyone to join seems really bad
it's probably something similar to the guild CP on the graal site where you can open your guild up to applications and then approve new members based on applicants
This seems more probable. Although, it may also be a case where certain ranks will be able to get points for the guild. We were able to see on another thread (https://www.graalians.com/forums/sho...&postcount=287
) that there were 10 ranks you can create. Maybe guild leaders can set a rank when players are allowed to gain points for the guild.
I feel if members of guilds were able to earn points for the guild right away, a lot of sabotage from other guilds will occur making a huge problem and possibly toxicity in the towering community. The system I thought up above may prevent some of this from happening.
If the system I thought up did happen to be the system, demoting members should make the guild lose points as it can be abused by players.
I don't know. These are my thoughts, but Thallen's idea does seem likely.