The way I see it is that all of the items are good. They all look well made and that's great but the problem for me is that nothing stands out as something amazing. They're just more thanksgiving items
. I think that's fair though because you can't really create anything super unique with a theme like this and a lot of people will still buy all of the items being sold.
To be fair, how creative can you possibly be around the theme of thanksgiving? I think the GFX team should use the month of November to work on personal projects such as a set to be sold in Bazaar, a well-made GST hat, or update one of the many shops around the game. Making a new turkey themed outfit, mount, or morph is just a waste of time.
Shops being updated right before Black Friday would be dope.
This is a good idea but I don't think it should happen during this time of the year. It would cause a lot of backlash from the average player because they'd be removing a revolution event which a lot of people look forward to. If my memory is serving me right, nothing much happens around the middle of the year besides july 4th right? Maybe they could spend some time during those months to work on the things you listed.