For my idea I was thinking a to add a new feature call "Guild Logs" (or whatever you guys can call it).So that the leader can see the list of member on how many hours help on the guild, so basically it goes like this for example:

Guild: illusive

Members:
(I'll just pick 5 random members)

-Thallen helped 340 hours
-Mae helped 310 hours
-Memo helped 260 hours
-Livid helped 170 hours
-Alexis helped 100 hours
(I am making these numbers up as for example)

But yeah it can also organize different categories like daily, monthly and all time.

My second idea that to add a new indicator color (red or black) that will shows members that are AFK for few minutes . And this effect that it will freeze the hours that helped so that they won't boost on towering (aka slacking and cheating), and when the person is back active it will show green again.

And lastly another idea is that it can shows the members that got recruited and kicked, and that it should show category reasons for being kicked like AFK, Space, or Other [describe the reason]

Like this:


Thallen recruited Zicknex
Memo Kicked Tasai
- Reason [@Other]: For inappropriate behavior
Mae Kicked Alexis
- Reason: AFK

So yeah these are my ideas for the guild system and this will definitely help
leaders to give hats the the members they deserved on who as many hours ^^

Feel free to comment and adding additional ideas (:  

Pretty sure people have suggested for a long time to show logs for kicking members. Not sure why it never was made, though. It would actually be a good quality improvement for guilds. The rest sounds a lot like what Ol' West has. I'm not sure that many guilds care how long you actually "help". Most guilds know who helps and who doesn't, and then you can still only judge "helping" by how much time they're in a base without having gone AFK. There's no problem with it, but I don't see much need or desire for that aspect of a guild log. I doubt that there will ever be a reason category for kicking members from a guild. If there were logs made available to guild members, it would just show player1 kicked player2.  

Posted by Zorma Knight

For my idea I was thinking a to add a new feature call "Guild Logs" (or whatever you guys can call it).So that the leader can see the list of member on how many hours help on the guild, so basically it goes like this for example:

Guild: illusive

Members:
(I'll just pick 5 random members)

-Thallen helped 340 hours
-Mae helped 310 hours
-Memo helped 260 hours
-Livid helped 170 hours
-Alexis helped 100 hours
(I am making these numbers up as for example)

But yeah it can also organize different categories like daily, monthly and all time.

My second idea that to add a new indicator color (red or black) that will shows members that are AFK for few minutes . And this effect that it will freeze the hours that helped so that they won't boost on towering (aka slacking and cheating), and when the person is back active it will show green again.

And lastly another idea is that it can shows the members that got recruited and kicked, and that it should show category reasons for being kicked like AFK, Space, or Other [describe the reason]

Like this:


Thallen recruited Zicknex
Memo Kicked Tasai
- Reason [@Other]: For inappropriate behavior
Mae Kicked Alexis
- Reason: AFK

So yeah these are my ideas for the guild system and this will definitely help
leaders to give hats the the members they deserved on who as many hours ^^

Feel free to comment and adding additional ideas (:

Meow  

This would be very pointless as for the first section people would just afk to get as many hours possible down  

Posted by Saber Alumba

This would be very pointless as for the first section people would just afk to get as many hours possible down

Well I was also curious about that till she told me that if both the indicators idea and the log idea were implemented then the logs would stop counting for those who go afk.  

Posted by Livid

Well I was also curious about that till she told me that if both the indicators idea and the log idea were implemented then the logs would stop counting for those who go afk.

It would help yes however detecting someone is afk is difficult, i mean you aren't gonna move much if your not being attacked in tower so that would penalise your hours helped even tho you might be wide awake.  

Posted by Saber Alumba

It would help yes however detecting someone is afk is difficult, i mean you aren't gonna move much if your not being attacked in tower so that would penalise your hours helped even tho you might be wide awake.

Plus it doesn't actually show if you help. It really just shows that you moved at least once every 5 minutes. If wehad this system, it would have showed helped a ton in some guilds, when really I just was there and in the tower to mess with the guild members and talk to them.  

Posted by Saber Alumba

It would help yes however detecting someone is afk is difficult, i mean you aren't gonna move much if your not being attacked in tower so that would penalise your hours helped even tho you might be wide awake.

I agree with the not being attacked part, idk how itd work for that, but its very possible to add since the game already detects if someone is afk and I dont know if its difficult or not its up to dusty's skills.  

It could also show how many kills each guild member has for the day, week, and season. That along with the hours they've helped would tell a lot.  

nice idea, i think it would help a lot  

This would help so much in Ol West and any Graal Server but don't think the Afk function would workout the way everyone would want.  

If they can do something like that, then sure. Pretty cool ideas.

Gotta wait and see what the guild update will do, because maybe this won't be necessary for what that have planned.  

Every single thing is good, but the AFK one is probably a flaw  

Posted by Zorma Knight

For my idea I was thinking a to add a new feature call "Guild Logs" (or whatever you guys can call it).So that the leader can see the list of member on how many hours help on the guild, so basically it goes like this for example:

Guild: illusive

Members:
(I'll just pick 5 random members)

-Thallen helped 340 hours
-Mae helped 310 hours
-Memo helped 260 hours
-Livid helped 170 hours
-Alexis helped 100 hours
(I am making these numbers up as for example)

But yeah it can also organize different categories like daily, monthly and all time.

My second idea that to add a new indicator color (red or black) that will shows members that are AFK for few minutes . And this effect that it will freeze the hours that helped so that they won't boost on towering (aka slacking and cheating), and when the person is back active it will show green again.

And lastly another idea is that it can shows the members that got recruited and kicked, and that it should show category reasons for being kicked like AFK, Space, or Other [describe the reason]

Like this:


Thallen recruited Zicknex
Memo Kicked Tasai
- Reason [@Other]: For inappropriate behavior
Mae Kicked Alexis
- Reason: AFK

So yeah these are my ideas for the guild system and this will definitely help
leaders to give hats the the members they deserved on who as many hours ^^

Feel free to comment and adding additional ideas (:

Like your ideas but the idea that the leader gets to choose eh maybe who contributed the
most also you avatar is cute  

Posted by Livid

I agree with the not being attacked part, idk how itd work for that, but its very possible to add since the game already detects if someone is afk and I dont know if its difficult or not its up to dusty's skills.

Sends a message, moves around, hits the sword buttom=active