As long as you talked to it and are nearby the NPC it will prompt the "how much candy do you want to give?" thing. But yeah it's annoying cause I've forgotten that I had the candy equipped afterwards and eaten it ~3-5 times now.  

Saved up my first 5 candies and used them all on one trick-or-treater. Got a cool bone mirror.
 

can admins post something saying "hey If u trade this amount of candies theres a chance you might get this! because I'm not really into furniture but the furniture is pretty good  

Posted by Ivy

and beans that are just tricks is a SERIOUS rip off.

How are the beans tricks? They're purely cosmetic. The idea is based off Harry Potter's "every flavor beans".  

Posted by Coco

How are the beans tricks? They're purely cosmetic. The idea is based off Harry Potter's "every flavor beans".

Cool but not cool because they are too prevalent but good idea id say make prize chance higher though good job though  

Posted by Coco

How are the beans tricks? They're purely cosmetic. The idea is based off Harry Potter's "every flavor beans".

They're one use items with no value whatsoever.  

Posted by Ruppy

Ok i have question i got first candy and if i turn it in do i automatically get a trick cuz its only one or can i get a treat?

At first try I gave him 5 candies and got tricked. Second try only gave 1 and got a gold gralat. I think it is choosen randomly.  

Do the little goblin guys come out of bushes or do they just appear? They seem to appear a lot at the right side bushes when entering Swamp town, but I can't tell if it's because of the bushes or if they're just spawning there.  

Posted by Sophia*

At first try I gave him 5 candies and got tricked. Second try only gave 1 and got a gold gralat. I think it is choosen randomly.

You gave 1 candy and got a gold grant? I gave 9 for a gold gralat your right it is random...

Let the hate comments roll in but i liked last year better... it was easier to get candy and there weren't any tricks  

Posted by Ivy

I honestly feel like we should be compensated in some way for this. spending 100+ candies and getting two items, and beans that are just tricks is a SERIOUS rip off.

The beans are funny, but.. otherwise this is a compkete and utter rip off.  

F this year you have like 5 ****ing mobs happening around graal for 1 ghost which basically means you can catch that ghost . The ghost always lags back and I always get tricked. Wtf man  

I'd be more sympathetic to increase the treat rate if the average candy given to Trick or Treaters wasn't 2.  

Dusty no one will trade more than two either unless you make them like some years (had to trade 5) or if you actually explain the odds of what you can get by trading in more than one or there are people like me who take risks and trade 9 for gold gralat. Human nature is cheap so it will keep trading likely two but if more candy is obtained (preferable in other ways then ghosts and goblins that doesn't have 50 people in one spot)then more candy will be traded in.  

Posted by Dusty

I'd be more sympathetic to increase the treat rate if the average candy given to Trick or Treaters wasn't 2.

I gave out about 60 candy in 10's I got a gold grakats and 4 jelly beans. If thats not enough, its a dub. I say return about 20 candy to everyone, and rise the rate cuz this is seriously pissing me off.  

Posted by Ruppy

You gave 1 candy and got a gold grant? I gave 9 for a gold gralat your right it is random...

Let the hate comments roll in but i liked last year better... it was easier to get candy and there weren't any tricks

Gave 2 candy and got a fence, while my friend had to give 15 for the same fence..
And true, last graaloween you could choose yourself what you wanted with the grab bags.