Guild Idea! - 2

ufoburan · 08-04-2013

Maybe when a player gets a 1k hat they could get some kind of medal or something marking there status showing they got 1k with a guild. If they have that medal then they are no longer able to get 1k hat's thus only 1 1k hat per person or account. That might curb the recycling guilds. Ppl would still be able to help other guilds get to 1k they just wouldn't be able to get the hat. Maybe they could get gralats instead.

qes · 08-04-2013

the same guilds wont win everytime nobody gets special treatement anyone can make a tpwer guild it just requires people and SoN is 5% of graal at most so... stop complaining

Hadzz · 08-04-2013

This idea would never happen its too unfair on everybody except people who spend there entire life on this game just pking

ZigZag44 · 08-05-2013

Posted by qes

the same guilds wont win everytime nobody gets special treatement anyone can make a tpwer guild it just requires people and SoN is 5% of graal at most so... stop complaining

do you own a tower gild, or are you in one? and yes, the same guilds will win every time, look at tower scoreboard, and we arent complaining, were telling you this wont happen because the same guilds will win and its unfair for the other guilds

Hadzz · 08-05-2013

How do you get ten k

ufoburan · 08-07-2013

Posted by ZigZag44

do you own a tower gild, or are you in one? and yes, the same guilds will win every time, look at tower scoreboard, and we arent complaining, were telling you this wont happen because the same guilds will win and its unfair for the other guilds

^this

look at the guild scores everyday for tower time guarenteed SON will be on top of it. followed by Vintage then who ever else right now probably door blockers GEM.

Aaron · 08-07-2013

Posted by Hadzz

This idea would never happen its too unfair on everybody except people who spend there entire life on this game just pking

Well, shouldn't those who put in the most effort get the largest reward?

meganey98 · 08-08-2013

Kes the kiki!!

Hadzz · 08-08-2013

Posted by Aaron

Well, shouldn't those who put in the most effort get the largest reward?

Not rly pkining Isn't a true skill as anyone can use a sword on someone at 0.5 but graals best archer can't start a guild even though she's the best in one on one combat

twilit · 08-09-2013

Not rly pkining Isn't a true skill as anyone can use a sword on someone at 0.5 but graals best archer can't start a guild even though she's the best in one on one combat

wat r u even talking about?? dis thred iz about guildz not pking, they r talking about 1k hat rewardz

Hadzz · 08-09-2013

Posted by twilit

wat r u even talking about?? dis thred iz about guildz not pking, they r talking about 1k hat rewardz

I know that but we went a bit of topic o.k

mithos · 08-09-2013

This isnt fair for lots of newcomers...
1.Guilds like SON and Chain of Memories are basically made of friends that play daily
2. Guilds that are recruiting have no people that are loyal
3. Whats wrong with this topic? Did u have a hatchaser in your guild :/
4. People who agreed are obviously part of one of those guilds... -In the end its all about you

Aaron · 08-10-2013

Posted by Hadzz

Not rly pkining Isn't a true skill as anyone can use a sword on someone at 0.5 but graals best archer can't start a guild even though she's the best in one on one combat

Effort=time. PKing=time. Same as sparring. And who is this "she"?

Haavard · 08-10-2013

I have thought about this myself. I have chosen not to suggest this because from my point of view; the same guilds would be top 3 over and over.
Now that's one problem, but if you want to start up a new guild, you have to be ready within the first few days of a new season. (If you are aiming for the top 3).

If you are looking to be rewarded for your work it would look much more appealing to join an already established guild, rather than joining a new one. You might aswell join the guild that has been on the top 3 the last X amount of seasons, at least you are likely to get something back for the hours you spend attacking and defending the forts.

Now that's my opinion.

I also see people wanting to remove the 1k fort hats, which I don't think is a good idea either. There are other ways of preventing people from making guilds going to 1k then join a new one, and so on ... .

Something I would like to suggest concerning a change to the 1k hat chasing.

Make a restriction where a player may only receive a 1k hat once every half or quarter year. I.E. 6 or 3 months after they received their last 1k OR 5k hat.

In order for this to work out properly, only identified accounts should be eligible to receive guild hats. This prevent the hats to be given to a non identified account and then transferred onto the identified one. (They would have separated timers for receiving the 1k hat).

The ones who only want to take fort for hats will now either have to continue with the guild; maybe going for another hat at 5k. Or they may wait 3-4 months before they start up a new guild.
This will make it easier for other players to start up their guilds with new players who have not received a 1k hat the last 6 months. If they choose to continue, we will see more guilds reaching further than 1k before they quit. Which I think would be really nice.

Now this should also count for the 5k hat so people don't join in with their friends guild that has passed 4k hours and take a hat instead of someone who has worked since maybe 2-3k fort hours.

I know this may be too long for most to read, so I will sum it all up in a few lines:

- I don't like the idea of seasonal hats, it will make it hard to start up new guilds IMO.
- Restrict players from receiving fort hats more often than 3 or 6 months after they received their last fort hat.

Please give opinions if you bothered reading my whole comment.

ufoburan · 08-10-2013

I all ready said I disagree with seasonal rewards. I also came up with a similar idea in another thread about putting time restrictions on milestone reward (1k)hats. Imo that maybe the only way to keep people more "honest" with the way the current towering system is set up. There are to many hat chasers that jump in guilds in the last 100-200 hours trying to slide in on the hat list.

The only fear I have is that it may take away interest in towering. If ppl cant get the reward then why bother to tower at all?

08-04-2013	16
ufoburan Registered User Join Date: Apr 2013 Posts: 1,682	Maybe when a player gets a 1k hat they could get some kind of medal or something marking there status showing they got 1k with a guild. If they have that medal then they are no longer able to get 1k hat's thus only 1 1k hat per person or account. That might curb the recycling guilds. Ppl would still be able to help other guilds get to 1k they just wouldn't be able to get the hat. Maybe they could get gralats instead.

08-04-2013	17
qes Registered User Join Date: Jan 2012 Posts: 732	the same guilds wont win everytime nobody gets special treatement anyone can make a tpwer guild it just requires people and SoN is 5% of graal at most so... stop complaining

08-04-2013	18
Hadzz Inactive? Join Date: Jun 2013 Location: Near liverpool(uk) Posts: 1,676	This idea would never happen its too unfair on everybody except people who spend there entire life on this game just pking

08-05-2013	20
Hadzz Inactive? Join Date: Jun 2013 Location: Near liverpool(uk) Posts: 1,676	How do you get ten k

08-08-2013	23
meganey98 Megan (Providence) Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: United States Posts: 863	Kes the kiki!!

08-09-2013	27
mithos totoro Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Outside Battle Arena Posts: 345	This isnt fair for lots of newcomers... 1.Guilds like SON and Chain of Memories are basically made of friends that play daily 2. Guilds that are recruiting have no people that are loyal 3. Whats wrong with this topic? Did u have a hatchaser in your guild :/ 4. People who agreed are obviously part of one of those guilds... -In the end its all about you

08-10-2013	29
Haavard Registered User Join Date: Dec 2011 Posts: 11	I have thought about this myself. I have chosen not to suggest this because from my point of view; the same guilds would be top 3 over and over. Now that's one problem, but if you want to start up a new guild, you have to be ready within the first few days of a new season. (If you are aiming for the top 3). If you are looking to be rewarded for your work it would look much more appealing to join an already established guild, rather than joining a new one. You might aswell join the guild that has been on the top 3 the last X amount of seasons, at least you are likely to get something back for the hours you spend attacking and defending the forts. Now that's my opinion. I also see people wanting to remove the 1k fort hats, which I don't think is a good idea either. There are other ways of preventing people from making guilds going to 1k then join a new one, and so on ... . Something I would like to suggest concerning a change to the 1k hat chasing. Make a restriction where a player may only receive a 1k hat once every half or quarter year. I.E. 6 or 3 months after they received their last 1k OR 5k hat. In order for this to work out properly, only identified accounts should be eligible to receive guild hats. This prevent the hats to be given to a non identified account and then transferred onto the identified one. (They would have separated timers for receiving the 1k hat). The ones who only want to take fort for hats will now either have to continue with the guild; maybe going for another hat at 5k. Or they may wait 3-4 months before they start up a new guild. This will make it easier for other players to start up their guilds with new players who have not received a 1k hat the last 6 months. If they choose to continue, we will see more guilds reaching further than 1k before they quit. Which I think would be really nice. Now this should also count for the 5k hat so people don't join in with their friends guild that has passed 4k hours and take a hat instead of someone who has worked since maybe 2-3k fort hours. I know this may be too long for most to read, so I will sum it all up in a few lines: - I don't like the idea of seasonal hats, it will make it hard to start up new guilds IMO. - Restrict players from receiving fort hats more often than 3 or 6 months after they received their last fort hat. Please give opinions if you bothered reading my whole comment.