Guilds

Eldon · 03-05-2013

Being in tower guilds, and regular guilds, ive realised there is a lot of confusion to who kicked, when not supposed to be, or who was recruited, or recruiting "banned" players. So a quick idea i thought of was to make a log of who was kicked and recruited. No need for chat, because i feel that could be swamped. Also, to have a "banned player" list, which doesnt allow a person to be recruited while on that list. Would be a small, but (in my opinion) useful tool. It would be open to guild leader and all those the leader gave access to(another permission box). Just an idea

Xavier · 03-05-2013

I've wanted this for years.

Yes please.

HON3Y BADG3R · 03-05-2013

Yes. Absolutely yes.

GotenGraal · 03-05-2013

yes

Santa Claus · 03-05-2013

I don't think members should have the power to move people onto the banned list but only the leader.

PennyShine · 03-05-2013

Yes. I was so sick of the drama in bl that would come from "Who kicked her again?" "She's a lead, stop kicking her!" "Dafuq stop recruiting him he spams us with bs." This would be very helpful.

Smoke · 03-05-2013

For me the easiest solution is : For the leader to be able to have make leaders/perm unkickable meaning no other perms with kick powers would be able to kick them just the leader of the guild. ( just the way those with powers can't kick the leader itself )

MrSimons · 03-06-2013

If you aren't abusing the guild system this isn't a problem.

AimeeAdelphos · 03-06-2013

Posted by Smoke

For me the easiest solution is : For the leader to be able to have make leaders/perm unkickable meaning no other perms with kick powers would be able to kick them just the leader of the guild. ( just the way those with powers can't kick the leader itself )

I agree with this. You should be able to have "unkickable" members. Like when you're powering there's an option to "perm" them as well.

Blueh · 03-06-2013

The only downside I can see to this is if you end up perming the wrong person. But that's all on the leader, now isn't it?

Rufus · 03-06-2013

Lol the guild system will never intentionally cater for this 'perm' / 'temp' system that people use. That is not the purpose of a guild.

Zetectic · 03-06-2013

Posted by MrSimons

If you aren't abusing the guild system this isn't a problem.

if u are the ldr it is a problem.

Posted by Rufus

Lol the guild system will never intentionally cater for this 'perm' / 'temp' system that people use. That is not the purpose of a guild.

whatever that is, most of us want to have a list of kick or recruited history.

Eldon · 03-06-2013

Posted by Rufus

Lol the guild system will never intentionally cater for this 'perm' / 'temp' system that people use. That is not the purpose of a guild.

But it would be a plus to see who kicked who, and who recruited. It doesnt just cater to tower guilds, it would be a tool for all types. Also a banned player list to keep out spammers, people who are innapropriate, or even just rude. Maybe going as far as having a "kill minimum" or "hour minimum" to enter the guild. All could be done manually, but i think it would be something good to have.

MrSimons · 03-06-2013

Posted by Zetectic

if u are the ldr it is a problem.

My point was if you are using the guild system for what it was made for there is no issue, which would be recruiting friends and not random nubs you pick up at the burger refuge. In which case kicking members is hardly necessary.

Posted by Eldon

But it would be a plus to see who kicked who, and who recruited. It doesnt just cater to tower guilds, it would be a tool for all types. Also a banned player list to keep out spammers, people who are innapropriate, or even just rude. Maybe going as far as having a "kill minimum" or "hour minimum" to enter the guild. All could be done manually, but i think it would be something good to have.

Kill minimum is just yelling noob recruit.

Zetectic · 03-06-2013

Posted by Eldon

But it would be a plus to see who kicked who, and who recruited. It doesnt just cater to tower guilds, it would be a tool for all types. Also a banned player list to keep out spammers, people who are innapropriate, or even just rude. Maybe going as far as having a "kill minimum" or "hour minimum" to enter the guild. All could be done manually, but i think it would be something good to have.

lol, don't wish banned player list. its gonna take few scripted codes and lag more.

03-05-2013	1
Eldon Registered User Join Date: Feb 2013 Location: Battle Arena Bench Posts: 277	Guilds Being in tower guilds, and regular guilds, ive realised there is a lot of confusion to who kicked, when not supposed to be, or who was recruited, or recruiting "banned" players. So a quick idea i thought of was to make a log of who was kicked and recruited. No need for chat, because i feel that could be swamped. Also, to have a "banned player" list, which doesnt allow a person to be recruited while on that list. Would be a small, but (in my opinion) useful tool. It would be open to guild leader and all those the leader gave access to(another permission box). Just an idea

03-05-2013	2
Xavier Classic Join Date: Aug 2011 Location: New York City Posts: 908	I've wanted this for years. Yes please.

03-05-2013	3
HON3Y BADG3R The Cooliest? Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 1,117	Yes. Absolutely yes.

03-05-2013	4
GotenGraal helo utub Join Date: Feb 2012 Posts: 1,225	yes

03-05-2013	5
Santa Claus Scrubs. Join Date: Sep 2011 Location: I live in space Posts: 2,272	I don't think members should have the power to move people onto the banned list but only the leader.

03-05-2013	6
PennyShine Lsimhbiwfefmtalol Join Date: Dec 2012 Location: Forum Games/Classic Posts: 399	Yes. I was so sick of the drama in bl that would come from "Who kicked her again?" "She's a lead, stop kicking her!" "Dafuq stop recruiting him he spams us with bs." This would be very helpful.

03-05-2013	7
Smoke Registered User Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: US Posts: 394	For me the easiest solution is : For the leader to be able to have make leaders/perm unkickable meaning no other perms with kick powers would be able to kick them just the leader of the guild. ( just the way those with powers can't kick the leader itself )

03-06-2013	8
MrSimons :) Join Date: Sep 2011 Location: no. Posts: 10,309	If you aren't abusing the guild system this isn't a problem.

03-06-2013	10
Blueh The Orator Join Date: Sep 2011 Location: Yes Posts: 3,307	The only downside I can see to this is if you end up perming the wrong person. But that's all on the leader, now isn't it?

03-06-2013	11
Rufus Registered rufp4 Join Date: Jan 2011 Posts: 3,378	Lol the guild system will never intentionally cater for this 'perm' / 'temp' system that people use. That is not the purpose of a guild.