Posted by Toad

I have the game and it sucks, we are stuck in 1.6.6, no mods, no anything.

The game had to be recoded from scratch. And I mean absolutely recoded. Minecraft is made in Java and of course, Java doesn't run Xbox. So the game had to be recoded to XNA. Not to mention currently Minecraft uses a seperate server/client foundation which wouldn't work with the Xbox. So the multiplayer aspect had to be completely reinvisioned and streamlined. Not to mention various other changes such as fixing the interface to better work with a controller and so on. Such a gap between the two versions was to be expected. The fact that they got as far as 1.6.6 is amazing, imo. Look at the mobile version, it's still stuck with pretty much ONLY creative mode... and the Android OS RUNS JAVA.

Posted by Toad

You need an HDTV in order to do splitscreen (wtf). Or you need to buy an HDMI Cable. I personally think that is the stupidest idea ever since you can already play it by yourself.

Not really, it's for your own good. Without HD you're working with a resolution of 480 AT BEST. Split that and you're only working with 240 resolution. That would look horrible, and you probably wouldn't be able to properly see beyond five blocks in the distance.

Posted by Toad

However, it just "feels" nicer that playing on the PC.

Ah, good ol' console gaming. Always feels better.

Posted by Toad

Also, Notch announced that it is going to be Xbox360 only, no PSN involved. However, I can't quite remember where I've seen this statement.

This was announced when it was first announced, he signed a contract with Microsoft.

Posted by Toad

or lack of multiplayer (A scam),

What? It DOES feature multiplayer, either 4 player splitscreen(isn't their problem you don't have an HDTV or 8 player online. It can't manage the multiplayer structure the PC version has because Xboxes can't handle that sort of workload. I also don't see how it's a scam as the multiplayer modes(1-8 players) were advertised.

Posted by Toad

Small Map (Limited Gameplay),

This does suck regardless. I hated it on the mobile system, too. I wish they could figure out a way to work it out. The problem again is that the 360's hardware probably just couldn't do all the crunching involved in generating chunks on the fly. Not to mention that world sizes can get quite large(they probably don't want people filling up their HDD's. Even a casually explored world can hit a few GBs.)

Posted by Toad

No mods will ever be on it (Announced by Notch),

Not surprising. Not even PC has actual mods, they're just "hacks" and not officially supported in any way.

Posted by Toad

No PSN (Fail),

Chances are Microsoft approached them with the contract. Exclusive titles are nothing new.

Posted by Toad

Only 8 players per server (Huh?),

I addressed this above.

I don't have the game, but these problems seem pretty obvious. Most of them are outside of anyones current control, and I feel people should let up. Now the mobile version of Minecraft SUCKS ASS. I wouldn't suggest it even for $6. It is WAY more behind than the 360 version, and the controls suck ass and the world is insanely small. The fact that this version was completely redone by scratch in insanely small portion of time compared to how long Minecraft was(and still is) in development I find amazing. Perhaps they will catch up and Minecraft itself will port over to the code base of the 360 version and we can finally move away from ****ing Java.

This version may be lacking compared to the PC version, but it will probably catch up soon enough(way before the mobile version ever does ) and it's a GREAT way to expose Minecraft to an entirely different playerbase. There is an entirely different group of people out there who play consoles exclusively and never touched a game on the PC, so they'd probably never play Minecraft if it weren't for this version. Also this is a great way to get family/friends involved too without overwhelming them.  

Posted by Toad

I have the game and it sucks, we are stuck in 1.6.6, no mods, no anything. You need an HDTV in order to do splitscreen (wtf). Or you need to buy an HDMI Cable. I personally think that is the stupidest idea ever since you can already play it by yourself. The map borders are the size of one map (the item). 1000x1000 blocks, no further. You can't use a guest account either. However, it just "feels" nicer that playing on the PC. That's basically it, I wouldn't get it. Also, Notch announced that it is going to be Xbox360 only, no PSN involved. However, I can't quite remember where I've seen this statement. Overall, I'd rate Minecraft XBLA a 2/10, for lack of multiplayer (A scam), Small Map (Limited Gameplay), No mods will ever be on it (Announced by Notch), No PSN (Fail), Only 8 players per server (Huh?), the only upside is the swift and nice controls which makes Minecraft feel much better than on the PC. I would not get it, I'm trying to get myself a refund.

:0  

Posted by Toad

I have the game and it sucks, we are stuck in 1.6.6, no mods, no anything. You need an HDTV in order to do splitscreen (wtf). Or you need to buy an HDMI Cable. I personally think that is the stupidest idea ever since you can already play it by yourself. The map borders are the size of one map (the item). 1000x1000 blocks, no further. You can't use a guest account either. However, it just "feels" nicer that playing on the PC. That's basically it, I wouldn't get it. Also, Notch announced that it is going to be Xbox360 only, no PSN involved. However, I can't quite remember where I've seen this statement. Overall, I'd rate Minecraft XBLA a 2/10, for lack of multiplayer (A scam), Small Map (Limited Gameplay), No mods will ever be on it (Announced by Notch), No PSN (Fail), Only 8 players per server (Huh?), the only upside is the swift and nice controls which makes Minecraft feel much better than on the PC. I would not get it, I'm trying to get myself a refund.

Consoles dont have the RAM to infigenerate a map and the gameplay had to be completely recoded into C++ from java and they started it when 1.6 was released. So shut up. Like normal minecraft it will have updates and all the other features you ignorant idiot. It will be updated. Incase you didnt see the panel on the main menu saying " downloadable content" and what is such a huge deal about split screen? The online multiplayer is flawless and never lags. Im glad its staying XBL only. How are exlusive games a fail? And i seriously dbout anybody will ever need over 8 players at a time. The most ive had was 6 with 0 lag. Also, it states no refunds on every purchase, without even scrolling, good luck.

My only complaint is. That the night is wayyy to dark. Was smooth lighting defaulted before or after 1.6?

Also props to dusty for retaliating even better than i did.

I am bummed at no mods but maybe a. Online petition for mod devs to be able to submit them as DLC to XBLAMC. Serriously enough people can make anything happen. And mc has a HUGEE fanbase. The mass effect ending was changed with 500,000 people? Couldnt take much to just alow mods?  

Posted by spades of feare

Consoles dont have the RAM to infigenerate a map and the gameplay had to be completely recoded into C++ from java and they started it when 1.6 was released. So shut up. Like normal minecraft it will have updates and all the other features you ignorant idiot. It will be updated. Incase you didnt see the panel on the main menu saying " downloadable content" and what is such a huge deal about split screen? The online multiplayer is flawless and never lags. Im glad its staying XBL only. How are exlusive games a fail? And i seriously dbout anybody will ever need over 8 players at a time. The most ive had was 6 with 0 lag. Also, it states no refunds on every purchase, without even scrolling, good luck.

My only complaint is. That the night is wayyy to dark. Was smooth lighting defaulted before or after 1.6?

Also props to dusty for retaliating even better than i did.

I am bummed at no mods but maybe a. Online petition for mod devs to be able to submit them as DLC to XBLAMC. Serriously enough people can make anything happen. And mc has a HUGEE fanbase. The mass effect ending was changed with 500,000 people? Couldnt take much to just alow mods?

Don't you think I know all this? I am not saying I absolutely hate it, I actually enjoy it a bit. But I just wrote a review on the facts, so theres no point in being rude by these comments: "you ignorant idiot" Plus, read the Minecraft Forums under the Xbox 360 gameplay edition I just added a bunch of other people's ideas too. So really, you don't need to be rude.  

Posted by Toad

Don't you think I know all this? I am not saying I absolutely hate it, I actually enjoy it a bit. But I just wrote a review on the facts, so theres no point in being rude by these comments: "you ignorant idiot" Plus, read the Minecraft Forums under the Xbox 360 gameplay edition I just added a bunch of other people's ideas too. So really, you don't need to be rude.

Sorry, three finals today. My appologies. But i will give it alot of credit. But you can do alot with a 1000x1000 grid  

Posted by spades of feare

Sorry, three finals today. My appologies. But i will give it alot of credit. But you can do alot with a 1000x1000 grid

I do agree  

Ohhhhh yes.
Just today I found out it was out!
I played the trial and; POOF I was absolutley in love.
I'll bebuying it soon, aswell!

I am so, so, so excited.



And good-job to Notch, and the rest of the employes from starting as a small Indie game, onto becoming Microsoft-Owned game!

THANKS, NOTCH!!  

So this game as pros and cons

Everygame has that!
The only problem i have with it is that you get killed to easily :/ and The lighting problem

oh btw did anyone notice that if u get a bucket of water and you place it on a piece of land it will disapear :/  

Thats a temp glitch. Also the nether is very glitchy. I recomend building your portal in a room or inside a cave.  

Yeah spades I built my portal and when I stepped in I fell in the lava. -_-  

Posted by John J Johnson

Yeah spades I built my portal and when I stepped in I fell in the lava. -_-

I cant determine where youll spawn in the nether, mine appears to be working. Wanna hang. On my server? I need more cobble miners for my castle. And a professional sheep shearer for the woll to decor it.  

Lack of analog control for camera movement is embarrassing. For shame developers, for shame.  

Posted by Dusty

Lack of analog control for camera movement is embarrassing. For shame developers, for shame.

Minecraft really isnt for 3rd person. The camera movement seems to be the same though.  

Posted by spades of feare

Minecraft really isnt for 3rd person. The camera movement seems to be the same though.

You do realize first person perspective has a camera too, right? It's just lodged in the player's face. The point is that when I use my analog stick the game either moves the camera at a set speed, or it doesn't. That sucks and there's a reason that every FPS since 2000 has had analog control. Lack of analog makes movement feel stiff and slow. You can crank up the sensitivity but then you lose precision.

It's a ****ing horrible oversight on the devs part.  

I find the control fine!


I just played with my sensitivity a bit!