As it stands, 'default' is the most ideal hit detection there has been on Graal for playing with, and it's the best we're ever going to get. Any changes to it will only make things worse. See horses, bombs, etc for an example of this.  

Posted by RYAN 12312

pointless thread :3

Then why bother posting on here if it's pointless?  

Maybe with better hit detection i could do better in spars  

Era's isn't that good lol  

Posted by Rufus

As it stands, 'default' is the most ideal hit detection there has been on Graal for playing with, and it's the best we're ever going to get. Any changes to it will only make things worse. See horses, bombs, etc for an example of this.

This.

/thread  

A good system could be implemented if graal stored players location for the last 5 seconds. When you swing, you send your current location and a timestamp to the server. It deducts the timestamp from the current time then checks if any players was in that spot at that time. If so, hit them. Otherwise, nothing. If over 5 seconds, reject and laugh at the player.

It's not going to be perfect but might make things better than what I have seen at times. This follows the method i've seen used on FPS  

Posted by Twinny

A good system could be implemented if graal stored players location for the last 5 seconds. When you swing, you send your current location and a timestamp to the server. It deducts the timestamp from the current time then checks if any players was in that spot at that time. If so, hit them. Otherwise, nothing. If over 5 seconds, reject and laugh at the player.

It's not going to be perfect but might make things better than what I have seen at times. This follows the method i've seen used on FPS

Mind = Blown  

Posted by Twinny

A good system could be implemented if graal stored players location for the last 5 seconds. When you swing, you send your current location and a timestamp to the server. It deducts the timestamp from the current time then checks if any players was in that spot at that time. If so, hit them. Otherwise, nothing. If over 5 seconds, reject and laugh at the player.

It's not going to be perfect but might make things better than what I have seen at times. This follows the method i've seen used on FPS

See I would rather not have that... :[

Anyway, classic only has a sword, bomb and bow so it's ok :p  

Posted by snk

See I would rather not have that... :[

Anyway, classic only has a sword, bomb and bow so it's ok :p

It would be quite intensive for the poor npc-server but potentially useable. Also provides validation so no cheating :-)