I really want to like anime, but I'm pretty picky. Can I get some recommendations?

For examples of what anime I've watched and genuinely liked: Tokyo Ghoul. Cowboy Beebop. Castlevania. One Punch Man. Gurren Lagann. Elfen Lied. School-Live. Steins-Gate. And the Fate series. Oh and Dragonball, and Dragonball Z as a kid.

For actual television: Firefly. Battlestar Galactica. The Office. The Expanse. Game of Thrones. Stranger Things. Most of the Marvel Netflix stuff. Arrested Development. And Breaking Bad.

I also watched parts of SAO and I did enjoy parts of it. Mostly the premise. Same with Hellsing Ultimate. Tried watching Fullmetal Alchemist but I don't really have the patience or time to watch these 50 - 60 episode shows so I lost interest.

I am a fan of the fantasy genre. If there can be a bit of tasteful romance that is a positive (no harems). I like my anime to be serious OR funny but generally not both. Obviously needs a well written story. I do prefer dubs over subs but it isn't required. Oh, and not a real huge fan of Gundam stuff.

EDIT: Include Btooom! and Attack on Titan. Somehow forgot them on my list. I guess I have watched a lot of anime over the years.