I'm going to say what I did like about the shop.
I really liked the levels, especially the lobby. The furniture room had quite a bit of empty space, but that's fine.
I bought the Jolly Flail and the Tree Dirk. I actually really liked the GANIs for both of them. If there's any problem with the GANI for the Flail, it's that the template doesn't have a smooth transition between the straight and bent views.
The lingering swing effect on the weapons was a nice addition. I haven't seen any other weapon quite have that effect yet; it's pretty original. A bit overdone, as it was added to every weapon, but that's fine I guess, considering they're all pretty much the same stat-wise.
There were a lot of good hats this year. I would have bought some had I had the money. Usually the holiday hats don't appeal to me, but I was quite surprised at how much I would have bought.
Overall, I thought Zone had a good Christmas shop.