Or just change it so it works like this:
1. Open cute present
2. Roll for item type inside cute category.
3. Roll for item inside that item type list(excluding items you already have from the list).
- If you already got all items from the list: repeat step 2
- If you have literally all cute items: roll between furniture(40%), gralats(40%) or food(20%).

Item types(probably forgetting about some stuff):
- Hats
- Mounts
- Accesoires
- Bombs
- Gani's (juggles, pogos, etc)
- Umbrella's
- Furniture(40%)/Gralats(40%)/food(20%) (Part of the same category, also the only types you can get duplicates with since the previous method doesn't apply to them.)

The percentages refer to the chances of those things being rolled