Pretty sure people have suggested for a long time to show logs for kicking members. Not sure why it never was made, though. It would actually be a good quality improvement for guilds. The rest sounds a lot like what Ol' West has. I'm not sure that many guilds care how long you actually "help". Most guilds know who helps and who doesn't, and then you can still only judge "helping" by how much time they're in a base without having gone AFK. There's no problem with it, but I don't see much need or desire for that aspect of a guild log. I doubt that there will ever be a reason category for kicking members from a guild. If there were logs made available to guild members, it would just show player1 kicked player2.