Posted by Coco

Okay well this is and always will be a no. 1k hats are already a pain so we're not about to let players edit staff-made GST hats. Pretty sure we don't even allow recolors on 1k hats once they've been uploaded. Only extremely minor edits, but those are even problematic due to the cache. If we let players edit GST hats then we'd either have to delete the original, remove it from the winners, upload the new version, and re-add it to the winners or the winners will just have to wait forever for the cache to update.

1k hats are one thing because the guild gets to design it and have someone of their choosing create it. They get to revise and edit it all they want before it's submitted, unlike GST hats where they are pre-made and they get to choose after they're already uploaded. Not only would it get incredibly annoying after some time, but it would be complicated because of the cache AND players may edit it in such a way that it would look really... really bad. So... No thanks.

Posted by Aguzo

Did I really? I don't think that I ever posted that, but a link would be nice.

Anyways, yes/no. I don't care if the hat that Drea made gets edited or not, it looks nice either way.

You wanted a recolor, I think because alumni has a lot of red/blue hats.
Blackout wanted the visor to be transparent. Basically preferences.
Contego wanted the helmet to also have "gst" on the back, but we didn't ask for that to not ask for too much. (Plus, then it wouldn't look as cosmetic, imo)

What I would like though, is for players and staff to come to terms and understand each other. Why edits aren't allowed or why they should be allowed if a certain set rules were given. These rules are just examples. There could be more towards the issue, which is why I am asking both parties.

For instance, some players feel like "at least 1st place should be allowed to upload their own hat." That can't be done, mostly, because they aren't staff and it's unsafe. (They could upload something from another game)