They won't and it's why I left Ol'West. What's the fun if your trying to use guns and everyone rushes at you with melees? At least change the hitbox with the melees. Make it slower? Reduce dmg? Something needs to be done. If HP is buffed then do what Shiz said. Buff the guns damage and keep melee damage same. Leave the melee fighting to Classic. I wanna see some good old Western gunplay.