This was my first Graalloween, and I thought it was pretty cool. The decorations and dark setting were awesome, and I though the Tailor Richaards costumes looked cool too. As for the event, I like the giving candy to Trick-or-Treaters concept. I also like that those Trick-or-Treaters are mischievous, making use of the "trick" part of Trick-or-Treat. Handouts aren't very fun. Apparently it was hard to get a treat the first day, but hard doesn't mean impossible. Plus they made it easier to get a treat anyways. Honestly, it's really not that hard to get candy. Yes, some of the ghosts are too laggy to be caught, but in my experience that's only in and around Graal City, where the most people are crowded around, causing the ghosts to warp. In other places a ghost appears, someone runs up, and they catch the candy. The goblins are an easy way to get candy. Anyone can throw some bushes or cut some grass, You can even catch bees on the side. The spawn rate was decreased, but that was only to stop people from mobbing at the larger bush and grass areas. They still spawn often enough to get your candy for the Trick-or-Treaters. As for there not being enough treats, in my opinion there is enough. 5 hats is just fine, for Trick-or-Treating. You want to collect more than 5 hats for one holiday? There are also the Onnet hats, the costume hats, and most likely more to come. There's also the furniture, a mount, and other one time use items. I'm pretty sure the fun of Halloween is going out and collecting candy to eat. That candy is one time use, you enjoy it and move on. Halloween is ultimately about enjoying it as it happens, and while it lasts. The jellybeans and such are an embodiment of that. The effects are cool. I don't know about you, but I enjoy them. There are other Halloween things that you can buy, so if you really want them then you can go buy them, but the Trick-or-Treating is really meant for fun. I think they did a good job. I got a lot of cool treats myself, and I've only been playing casually.