That argument is a crutch and only used when people have nothing else to say. Agreeing with guildmates, in particular the leader of the guild is a foreign concept to you apparently. I've disagreed with Thallen here before and I don't change views on those instances. On cases where we do agree though, it's often in scenarios where the person that we disagree with has nothing left to say so they break out this overused phrase.
With GOAT it's a running joke and I know not to take it seriously but the fact that you actually believe some of the stuff that you write on here is baffling.