Most tower guilds have all the permanent members in the sub guilds and they recruit only the online people to the main guild. If you had to keep them in forever, that would ruin this system. Also, Higbey's idea about older guilds getting 50 members is also kind of dumb... who cares how old the guild is? I made my guild in April of 2010 and i definitely don't need 50 spaces for people, it's just for friends. Being able to buy spaces sounds nice, but in reality it would be kind of pointless, and i can see tons of people complaining. Some things should just stay the same.