Graalians

Graalians (https://www.graalians.com/forums/index.php)
-   Classic Future Improvements (https://www.graalians.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   improve the in game report system (https://www.graalians.com/forums/showthread.php?t=34584)

Zetectic 03-05-2016 01:52 AM

improve the in game report system
 
the log button can be found in the menu, so you can access it through there. once you are in the report log. You will see two sections, people you've reported or you got reported.

Quote:

You have reported:
|Name: somegirl321(nublifez)|Reason: She speed hacks in spar|Status: not viewed|[Cancel]|
|Name: unixmad(umadmin)|Reason: didn't fixed the server|Status: viewed|[cancel]|
|Name: chocobo12yrold|Reason: being rude to me cus im old|Status: solved|[cancel]|
you have reported section features a cancel button, you can use it if you falsely report the person, changed your mind etc.
It shows who you reported, reason and the GP status to your report.

Quote:

You got reported:
|Reason: Zetetik harassd me on utube!!11|Status: viewed|
|Reason: this kid hax, he flawed me, LIFE DOESNT MAKE SENSE|Status: viewed|
|Reason: hes disturbing my boost omfg im pissed|Status: viewed|
in the other section, it shows the reason you were reported by other players and the status by GP.

i think this is a good addition for graal because we often misbelieve that report feature doesn't do anything. also if you see why you were reported, people will refrain from what they are doing. (like if they are bullying/verbally harassing someone). i also added a cancel feature, cause 2 nights ago, I accidentally reported a wrong pinoy girl. there was no way to turn things back. all i could do is hope that she didn't get into trouble because of what i did.

it's just an idea, feel free to add or argue me.

Ariona13 03-05-2016 02:50 AM

I see the 2nd section doesn't need to be added, That's just gonna make someone not wanna report them especially if the person your reporting is a friend in the community or if you report them they are going to ban evade and harass you....

Ding 03-05-2016 05:31 AM

Quote:

Posted by Ariona11 (Post 681276)
I see the 2nd section doesn't need to be added, That's just gonna make someone not wanna report them especially if the person your reporting is a friend in the community or if you report them they are going to ban evade and harass you....

2nd section doesn't state who reported them, if it did there would be a **** ton of unnecessary drama

Yog 03-05-2016 01:19 PM

Quote:

Posted by Ding (Post 681297)
2nd section doesn't state who reported them, if it did there would be a **** ton of unnecessary drama

If you're harassing someone and you are reported for harassment it's going to be obvious who reported you.

Zetectic 03-05-2016 02:45 PM

it's not just about harassment. that was just an example out of many. players have been banned cluelessly and some of them still don't know why they were banned. i'll throw in more examples.
Quote:

in response to yogurts quote: when the harassment goes on -people near by usually report the bully as well, so it's not gonna be 1 or 2 reports. and if the reporter is obvious? so what? if the bully doesn't stop, it's clear that they will be banned.
Quote:

saw a girl yesterday with a nick of 'giving away account pm me'.whether she was trolling or not, she didn't know JUST having that name on could get her into troubles. so I pm her and she was completely surprised and changed her name back to normal.
if i didn't pm her, next thing is pretty obvious, she will get banned for intentional scamming and she will be like 'wtf i didn't scam anyone' in the forum.
if the report log was in place, maybe it prevented her from getting banned without me pming her.
Quote:

a lagger, he gets reported for tower blocking (if that's still a thing). maybe he will stop doing that at least. cause we already know GP forces are brutal and heartless.
Quote:

stealing gralats. i pk in swamp, im pretty sure i was reported 50x for stealing gralats.
there were more example, it's morning can't think rn.

i personally think report log would help some people.
e.g. slim abuses his member to target one player.
people who were banned with 'no reason' could at least check their report log after they were banned.

PigParty 03-05-2016 03:17 PM

I would dislike this. People would do something until the saw they were reported, then stop. No one would retract their report that they already sent because it would probably only be retracted if you made friends again with someone or threatened them by reporting them and they did something so you would retract it. Both aren't viable reasons to retract a report. Also a GP would most likely a see a report before you'd have time to remove it anyways. This also just opens up the chance of attacks on players who report someone and completely removes the anonymity aspect to the report feature. Once you are dealt a punishment by a GP, you see the reason, or a GP can Pm/Warn you with a reason, so reports won't alert anyone to what they're doing wrong and cause them to stop. I see far more ways to abuse this than for how it could be helpful.

Zetectic 03-05-2016 03:55 PM

Quote:

Posted by PigParty (Post 681351)
I would dislike this. People would do something until the saw they were reported, then stop. No one would retract their report that they already sent because it would probably only be retracted if you made friends again with someone or threatened them by reporting them and they did something so you would retract it. Both aren't viable reasons to retract a report. Also a GP would most likely a see a report before you'd have time to remove it anyways. This also just opens up the chance of attacks on players who report someone and completely removes the anonymity aspect to the report feature. Once you are dealt a punishment by a GP, you see the reason, or a GP can Pm/Warn you with a reason, so reports won't alert anyone to what they're doing wrong and cause them to stop. I see far more ways to abuse this than for how it could be helpful.

that is a good point. so i changed my mind.
if you are concerned about that, maybe 2nd section should be offered after you have been banned/warned. so it doesn't go unnoticed to a player.

Weeno 03-05-2016 04:04 PM

maybe there could be an alert that says you've been reported. Nothing else

Bryan* 03-05-2016 04:33 PM

1 Attachment(s)
http://www.graalians.com/forums/atta...1&d=1457195172

Classic should really have this type of report system because:
1. It's simplistic and user-friendly
2. It has the reasons listed saving both players/admins time
3. States if a player abuses/false reports, they will be warned



Example:
Subject: Offensive Behavior
Reason: This player is swearing and writing explicit messages.

PigParty 03-05-2016 05:54 PM

@Bryan I agree. The only thing I dislike is it makes the reporting time longer, which can cause staff to not catch someone's chat. Overall, its pros outweigh the one small con I can think of.

rickclops 03-06-2016 02:11 AM

Nothing happens when you report people. But you get a warning if you put admin in your name or status. The only rule in graal is don't say the admins did something wrong.

Bryan* 03-06-2016 04:31 AM

Quote:

Posted by rickclops (Post 681586)
Nothing happens when you report people. But you get a warning if you put admin in your name or status. The only rule in graal is don't say the admins did something wrong.


Reminds me of the time I had on my status:
"Ignorant + Incompetent = GP's of Classic"

Result: status was reset lol

Count 03-06-2016 04:48 AM

Quote:

Posted by rickclops (Post 681586)
Nothing happens when you report people for no reason


ftfy

reports work as long as there is a staff member online

PigParty 03-06-2016 11:38 AM

Quote:

Posted by Bryan* (Post 681610)
Reminds me of the time I had on my status:
"Ignorant + Incompetent = GP's of Classic"

Result: status was reset lol

There's a word for that.... Corruption.

Bryan* 03-06-2016 02:16 PM

Quote:

Posted by PigParty (Post 681670)
There's a word for that.... Corruption.

I know there's corruption or tyranny if you're above the food chain. They should always remember it'll bite them in the future.


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:45 AM.

Powered by vBulletin/Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.