Scariest Horror Game you played
 

Mines probably fatal frame thats just scary.

So far, i say Dead Space

Dead Island for sure. And for movie Saw 3D.

All the Luna Games except the first one :3

Club Penguin all the way man

Resident Evil 4. I could not even get that far in the game without a zombie popping up aand freaking the hell out of me.

O.o Resident Evil 4 doesn't really get scary until you get to the underground portion.

I don't really play scary games.
Bioshock kinda creeped me out but also amazed me, happens to be one of my favorite games ever

When I got to the village I was already creeped out lol.

We don't go to Ravenholm. :(

(Not the scariest, but it came to mind...freaked me the hell out)

Club Penguin, for sure.

And let's not forget Graal.
http://i.imgur.com/NQgp4.png

The dreaded black vortex of jail!

Animal Crossing