|
Server voting
I see a lot of threads asking what the best or worst server is, but very rarely do I see people ever go in depth about what is good about the server. So I tried to come up with a short list of things where you can vote for which server succeeds the most in that category, and we could tally it up later to get some clarity on this.
This is strictly for iGraal servers, which include... iClassic, iEra, iZone, Delteria, and Ol'West. Please select only one server per category. And remember, before voting for a server, make sure you have played it a good bit! General Development: This category is about how the server looks, and whether or not you are going to be able to enjoy looking at game after a few hours of playtime. Best Tileset: Worst Tileset: Best Overall Graphics: Worst Overall Graphics Best Levels: Worst Levels: Cleanest Look: Uncut Look: for this category think in regards to clean, no in intrusive say2, no random text floating around on the gmap, consistent art style across the map, etc. Content: After you get past how the server actually looks, what sort of content is really in the server? Best HATS!: Worst hats: Strongest Immersion: Weakest Immersion: Strongest Roleplay capability: Weakest Roleplay capability: Money Earning- Best system(s): Money Earning- Worst system(s): Best Questing/Missions: Worst Questing/Missions: Most interesting overworld: Least interesting overworld: Most interesting NPCs: Least interesting NPCS: Creative Content: Carbon Copy Content: PVP: Player vs. Player action is a huge part of MMOs, and attracts a very large portion of a servers playerbase, how well does each server do? Best spar system: Worst spar system: Most balanced weapons: Least balanced weapons: Best system for basing/towering/planets...etc. Worst system for basing/towering/planets...etc. Best PK ability: Worst PK ability: Best control over stat boosting: Least control over stat boosting: Server Staff: This category is all about the server's staff team, how professional they are, and how well they work. Try to leave assumptions out of your votes, and base them purely off of what is actually being produced by the server, not what they say they will do, or what they say they are doing. Best Manager: Worst Manager: Most helpful PR department: Least helpful PR department: Most talented Dev team: Least talented Dev team: Most professional staff team: Least professional staff team: Most frequently keeps their promises: Least frequently keeps their promises: Most friendly overall staff: Least friendly overall staff: Values Player Feedback: Ignores Player Feedback: Playerbase: A big part of the server is the fanbase, the other people you are stuck playing with. Afterall, you wouldn't want to play on a game with people you don't like. Most helpful players: Least helpful players: Most diverse players: Least diverse players: Most closely knit community: Least closely knit community: Most friendly players: Least friendly players: "Least dumb" player base: Dumbest player base: |
I guess I can't really participate here. My immediate instinct is to vote for Classic for a lot of stuff, but I don't often get to the other servers so I can't really say.
However, I can point to specific instances of Classic that are good, which is where I think the discussion should lean towards instead of just arbitrarily voting different servers better than the others. Though one server may be "better" than the others in a general category, each server does something unique within that category that is worth mentioning. |
Quote:
Had the most potential: zone I feel like I was fairly unbiased, it may look like i'm "hating" on zone, but to be honest I kept my personal issues from my time as staff their to one side. At the end of the day I still really enjoyed doing missions and levelling up, but it just wasn't handled well enough, and once you got through that there is nothing else that keeps you there. And for the same reasons is what led me to vote classic for so many. I honestly find the gameplay repedative and boring, and have never experienced the same enjoyment after eras release, but their staff team is very structured and I admire their development work and core game play factors And I didn't fully read, and missed that you had included delteria. But as I have barely played it, and it technically isn't an ios server, there was no point including it for the most part. |
Quote:
As for Delteria, I don't consider it an iGraal server either (because it isnt), nor do I think it will be soon. However Delt is obviously closely tied to this community so I felt it might as well be included. |
Quote:
|
General Development:
This category is about how the server looks, and whether or not you are going to be able to enjoy looking at game after a few hours of playtime. Best Tileset: Classic Worst Tileset: Zone Best Overall Graphics: Era Worst Overall Graphics Classic, it's starting to get a bit bland. Best Levels: Delteria Worst Levels: Ol' west, it's the same as era ;-; Cleanest Look: Classic Uncut Look: Zone for this category think in regards to clean, no in intrusive say2, no random text floating around on the gmap, consistent art style across the map, etc. Content: After you get past how the server actually looks, what sort of content is really in the server? Best HATS!: Not classic, Era Worst hats: Zone Strongest Immersion: Weakest Immersion: Strongest Roleplay capability: Classic Weakest Roleplay capability: Era Money Earning- Best system(s): Classic, Money grows on trees! Money Earning- Worst system(s): Zone? Best Questing/Missions: Zone Worst Questing/Missions: Classic Most interesting overworld: Delteria Least interesting overworld: Classic Most interesting NPCs: Asaiki Least interesting NPCS: Asaiki Creative Content: their all great. Carbon Copy Content: - PVP: Player vs. Player action is a huge part of MMOs, and attracts a very large portion of a servers playerbase, how well does each server do? Best spar system: Era Worst spar system: Classic Most balanced weapons: Classic Least balanced weapons: Erwarawrsa. Best system for basing/towering/planets...etc. Zone Worst system for basing/towering/planets...etc. Classic Best PK ability: Era/Zone/Olwest/Delteria Worst PK ability: Classic Best control over stat boosting: Zone/Olwest/ Least control over stat boosting: Classic/Era Server Staff: This category is all about the server's staff team, how professional they are, and how well they work. Try to leave assumptions out of your votes, and base them purely off of what is actually being produced by the server, not what they say they will do, or what they say they are doing. Best Manager: - Worst Manager: - Most helpful PR department: - Least helpful PR department: - Most talented Dev team: - Least talented Dev team: - Most professional staff team: - Least professional staff team: -colin, just joking your doing a great job! Most frequently keeps their promises: - Least frequently keeps their promises: asaiki Most friendly overall staff: asaiki Least friendly overall staff: - Values Player Feedback: colin Ignores Player Feedback: admins who has 'pm me if you have problem about something' some are good. colin da best. Playerbase: A big part of the server is the fanbase, the other people you are stuck playing with. Afterall, you wouldn't want to play on a game with people you don't like. Most helpful players: asaiki Least helpful players: new players Most diverse players: mrsimon Least diverse players: latte: i demand equal rights! just joking your both good Most closely knit community: my grandma's sewing group. Least closely knit community: my aunts. Most friendly players: asaiki Least friendly players: - "Least dumb" player base: Era/Zone/Delteria/Olwest Dumbest player base: classic did i win |
Quote:
I'll cast my vote later. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
All of these posts quoting opinions that Mr Simons hasn't expressed is occasionally confusing.
|
General Development:
This category is about how the server looks, and whether or not you are going to be able to enjoy looking at game after a few hours of playtime. Best Tileset: Delteria Worst Tileset: Zone Best Overall Graphics: Delteria Worst Overall Graphics Ol' West Best Levels: Delteria Worst Levels: Era Cleanest Look: Classic Uncut Look: Ol'West for this category think in regards to clean, no in intrusive say2, no random text floating around on the gmap, consistent art style across the map, etc. Content: Delteria After you get past how the server actually looks, what sort of content is really in the server? Best HATS!: Classic Worst hats: Ol' West Strongest Immersion: Delteria Weakest Immersion: Zone Strongest Roleplay capability: Delteria Weakest Roleplay capability: Zone Money Earning- Best system(s):Delteria Money Earning- Worst system(s): Classic Best Questing/Missions: Delteria Worst Questing/Missions: Era Most interesting overworld: Delteria Least interesting overworld: Zone Most interesting NPCs: Delteria Least interesting NPCS: Zone Creative Content: Delteria Carbon Copy Content: Era/ Zone/ Ol' West PVP: Delteria Player vs. Player action is a huge part of MMOs, and attracts a very large portion of a servers playerbase, how well does each server do? Best spar system: Classic Worst spar system: Era Most balanced weapons: Classic Least balanced weapons: Era Best system for basing/towering/planets...etc. Classic Worst system for basing/towering/planets...etc. Zone Best PK ability: - Worst PK ability: Era Best control over stat boosting: - Least control over stat boosting: - Server Staff: Delteria, duh This category is all about the server's staff team, how professional they are, and how well they work. Try to leave assumptions out of your votes, and base them purely off of what is actually being produced by the server, not what they say they will do, or what they say they are doing. Best Manager: Warrlordd Worst Manager: - Most helpful PR department: - Least helpful PR department: - Most talented Dev team: Delteria/ Classic Least talented Dev team: Zone Most professional staff team: Delteria/ Classic(half half) Least professional staff team: Era Most frequently keeps their promises: - Least frequently keeps their promises: - Most friendly overall staff: Classic (Disney Smiles) Least friendly overall staff: - Values Player Feedback: - Ignores Player Feedback: - Playerbase: Delteria A big part of the server is the fanbase, the other people you are stuck playing with. Afterall, you wouldn't want to play on a game with people you don't like. Most helpful players: Delteria/ Classic Least helpful players: Era Most diverse players: Classic Least diverse players: - Most closely knit community: Delteria/ Classic Least closely knit community: Zone Most friendly players: - Least friendly players: - "Least dumb" player base: - Dumbest player base: - |
Best Tileset: Delteria
Worst Tileset: Zone Best Overall Graphics: Delteria Worst Overall Graphics: Zone Best Levels: Era Worst Levels: Zone Cleanest Look: Delteria Uncut Look: Zone for this category think in regards to clean, no in intrusive say2, no random text floating around on the gmap, consistent art style across the map, etc. Content: Delteria After you get past how the server actually looks, what sort of content is really in the server? Best HATS!: Classic Worst hats: Zone Strongest Immersion: Delteria Weakest Immersion: Zone Strongest Roleplay capability: Delteria Weakest Roleplay capability: Zone Money Earning- Best system(s): Delteria Money Earning- Worst system(s): Classic Best Questing/Missions: Delteria Worst Questing/Missions: Era Most interesting overworld: Delteria Least interesting overworld: Zone Most interesting NPCs: Delteria Least interesting NPCS: Zone Creative Content: Delteria Carbon Copy Content: Zone PVP: Player vs. Player action is a huge part of MMOs, and attracts a very large portion of a servers playerbase, how well does each server do? Best spar system: Classic Worst spar system: Era Most balanced weapons: Classic Least balanced weapons: Era Best system for basing/towering/planets...etc. Era Worst system for basing/towering/planets...etc. Delteria Best PK ability: Delteria Worst PK ability: Era Best control over stat boosting: - Least control over stat boosting: - Server Staff: This category is all about the server's staff team, how professional they are, and how well they work. Try to leave assumptions out of your votes, and base them purely off of what is actually being produced by the server, not what they say they will do, or what they say they are doing. Best Manager: WarrLordd Worst Manager: Tashkin Most helpful PR department: Era Least helpful PR department: Classic Most talented Dev team: Ol' West Least talented Dev team: Zone Most professional staff team: Era Least professional staff team: Zone Most frequently keeps their promises: Era Least frequently keeps their promises: Delteria Most friendly overall staff: Delteria Least friendly overall staff: Era Values Player Feedback: Ol' West Ignores Player Feedback: Classic Playerbase: A big part of the server is the fanbase, the other people you are stuck playing with. Afterall, you wouldn't want to play on a game with people you don't like. Most helpful players: Delteria Least helpful players: Zone Most diverse players: Delteria Least diverse players: Era Most closely knit community: Delteria Least closely knit community: Zone Most friendly players: Delteria Least friendly players: Era "Least dumb" player base: Era Dumbest player base: Zone |
I'm gonna have to do this tomorrow :o
|
General Development:
This category is about how the server looks, and whether or not you are going to be able to enjoy looking at game after a few hours of playtime. Best Tileset: ol'west Worst Tileset: zone Best Overall Graphics: Classic Worst Overall Graphics zone Best Levels: ol'west Worst Levels: era Cleanest Look: ol'west Uncut Look: era for this category think in regards to clean, no in intrusive say2, no random text floating around on the gmap, consistent art style across the map, etc. Content: After you get past how the server actually looks, what sort of content is really in the server? Best HATS!: classic Worst hats: zone Strongest Immersion: ol'west Weakest Immersion: era Strongest Roleplay capability: classic Weakest Roleplay capability: zone,ol'west,era Money Earning- Best system(s): ol'west (until patched) Money Earning- Worst system(s): era Best Questing/Missions: ol'west Worst Questing/Missions: era,zone Most interesting overworld: classic Least interesting overworld: era,zone Most interesting NPCs: classic Least interesting NPCS: era Creative Content: ol'west Carbon Copy Content: era PVP: Player vs. Player action is a huge part of MMOs, and attracts a very large portion of a servers playerbase, how well does each server do? Best spar system: classic Worst spar system: zone,era,ol'west Most balanced weapons: classic Least balanced weapons: ol'west/era Best system for basing/towering/planets...etc. classic Worst system for basing/towering/planets...etc. zone Best PK ability: classic Worst PK ability: zone Best control over stat boosting: classic Least control over stat boosting: ol'west Server Staff: This category is all about the server's staff team, how professional they are, and how well they work. Try to leave assumptions out of your votes, and base them purely off of what is actually being produced by the server, not what they say they will do, or what they say they are doing. Best Manager: xor Worst Manager: tashkin/snk (personal opinion) Most helpful PR department: ol'west (always friendly willing to talk) Least helpful PR department: classic (gps are horrible) Most talented Dev team: ol'west (as shown by alpho) Least talented Dev team: zone Most professional staff team: classic (been around longest even tho they aren't the best) Least professional staff team: zone (no-brainer) Most frequently keeps their promises: ol'west (shown since release) Least frequently keeps their promises: classic (lots of areas not released) Most friendly overall staff: ol'west (as referenced earlier) Least friendly overall staff: classic (abusive) Values Player Feedback: ol'west (as referenced earlier) Ignores Player Feedback: classic (100%) Playerbase: A big part of the server is the fanbase, the other people you are stuck playing with. Afterall, you wouldn't want to play on a game with people you don't like. Most helpful players: classic Least helpful players: era,zone,ol'west (all based on p2w) Most diverse players: classic Least diverse players: zone (all 13 and below) Most closely knit community: classic (as seen by gst, loyalty towards guilds) Least closely knit community: era Most friendly players: ol'west Least friendly players: era (they determine how good you are by how good you're gun is, enough said) "Least dumb" player base: classic (most of the players who have been around a while are more mature and a lot older) Dumbest player base: zone,era |
| All times are GMT. The time now is 11:02 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin/Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.