Posted by Jarace (Post 813113)

The door you showed me above is too large and covers the entirety of the player's body. If I recall correctly, the waterfall had the same issue but was also ripped directly from the files, as you said.
The stalls aren't allowed if they cover all of the player's body.

If you see any that break this rule let me know and they will be removed, though it's entirely possible they pre-date the uploading system.

Posted by Reggie* (Post 813115)

Having a slightly hard time understanding and Yes I see the idea with the chair.

Love the idea. Love making it into a furniture..except for the fact that we have to wait 6 months.

My idea with the shield is making it small enough to where is passes everything and then we use walls to cover the rest (Like we originally did before it was deleted.).

Here is what I did

Posted by 4-Lom (Post 813133)

I don't want to argue with you on this very useful thread, but the door shield clearly doesn't cover the body... Attachment 25652

When compared to, say, any of the 'bigshield' style shields, this is pretty minor coverage...
Attachment 25653
This shot, of course, is a shield on the default set of in-game shields.

The waterfall I had done used the colors from the game, but was drawn by hand and not matching the current in-game waterfalls though it was designed to fit the tileset.

As to reporting shields... Do you report a player wearing the shield or the shield code itself?

Posted by Jarace (Post 813151)

That shield will still be denied for being a direct rip from the tileset. We don't allow stuff based on the tileset either so if the door was the exact same size as a tileset door, I would still consider it based on the tileset.

I don't know how long it would take to get the furniture added somewhere, if it was made. But we shouldn't be allowing furniture as shields. I've contacted 4-Lom about this and asked for a list furniture items he would like to see, and anyone else is welcome to message me here with a similar list. I'll bring the suggestions to the appropriate people and see if they are interested in creating them. Sound good?


My mistake, it must have been a different waterfall shield that I'm thinking of. I also thought the side views of that door covered the entirety of the player, but I made that mistake when looking at the file in your post. Thanks for correcting me.

Posted by Reggie* (Post 813160)

I can edit the door. Or have someone else do it. But my main thing was getting a door shield through. I also wish to go into gun shields.

Classic is a Medieval type of game. Correct? Or the like "Classic" style.
Yet there has been a gaming nexus, a space nexus,as well as a techno
new years shop starting 2018 and military shop. Now
I have no clue why they were deleted. I assumed because its more "Era" like yet
we now have a military shop hat has cam back for the second time.
If possible, I would love a reason for their deletion.

Posted by Jarace (Post 813189)

The rule long precedes my time as Classic staff, and has been around since staff approved shields using the email. Classic currently has a very low recommended age (4+ I believe?), and guns aren't appropriate for that rating. There were also concerns about it clashing with the theme on Classic.

I see your point about the space station and retro gaming nexus, but this rule is not going anywhere.

Posted by Reggie* (Post 813194)

8-9+ but I understand. Perhaps one day it can be changed. But I guess not for now
Also do you know there is a gun shield currently out?

Posted by Reggie* (Post 813194)

8-9+ but I understand. Perhaps one day it can be changed. But I guess not for now
Also do you know there is a gun shield currently out?

Posted by Jarace (Post 809122)

No shields that act as in-game items or tiles.

Posted by Jarace (Post 813291)

We've added this denial reason to clarify our stance on things like the furniture shields, as well as stuff like banners and balloons that we have items for in-game.

Posted by 4-Lom (Post 813083)

After 4 years of having a shield that people have been using as a door in conjunction with a statue (seeing as though furniture objects have not been supplied to make such an item usable in designs) some one has decided to delete it.

I've drawn up the attached shield, which looks like a door and functions as a shield.
What rules does this break and how can it be made acceptable?

Attachment 25646

Posted by 4-Lom (Post 813295)

Why not make a template for actual custom banners?

Posted by Saeed (Post 815940)

The shield+body i’m currently wearing used to be a custom body upload for some players. Which means the tie with the body used to be one body, then my friend told me that few months ago or before that his body was removed with no refund or anything like that. The player is the leader of the guild No ap and his name is Shax>/3 (NO AP)
Why this body isn’t allowed? The tie isn’t really a shield and if you guys are counting it as a shield then would you not agree that a lot of similar custom bodies shouldn’t be allowed either? Please review this :)
Is there a possibility that the removal of the body was a mistake and this custom body is allowed?