What would you rate ol'west
 

Please rate the following!

1-10

Tileset-
storyline-
quests-
weapons-
fun-
friendly-
events-
updates-

Tileset- 3
Storyline- 0
Quests- 2
Weapons- 7
Fun- -3
Friendly- 5
Events- 0 (same as era)
Updates- 8

Events aren't same as Era,

Not that i dont like the events, but it is pretty much the exact same thing as Era @Shiz.
Has the event coin system like Era(except its called horse shoe's(clever idea)), it also has an event shop like Era, it also has the same event hosting concept with opening a door that leads to different type of events in each section. The exact same as Era

There are different events you know. So I'd stop referring to them as the exact same. (Not all, but there are new ones we introduced and still more to come.)

@ the event shop. Guessing Delteria and Zone is bad too for having their own event shop.

Tileset- 4. Not the original one and has borrowed Era tiles.
storyline- 8. Original story hasn't changed much, with the exception of the Union/Confederate storyline being cut completely.
quests- What quests?
weapons- 8. Very good, like iEra in the beginning, before it got autistic.
fun- 3. Not much to do other than PK and spar against bottom-laming 12 year olds.
friendly- 2. "Deputies" are trash.
events- N/A - I haven't been able to try any.
updates- N/A - We're three days in.

No point rating it at this current stage.
But from my point of view, it has been fairly enjoyable and has kept me occupied for a lot of hours; jobs, such as Gold panning, mining and just exploring is what made it fun for me considering it's a new server.

When will the event shop even be open?

It doesn't have a release date yet, but we were working on it last night. The level has been complete for awhile now. The images for items are complete too. All that's left is gani's and script.

Never said it was bad, said it was just like Era.

90 percent of the people complain about the fugly graphics.
You should do everything in your power to change that shouldn't you?
As is redo the tileset.

Why not? Every game gets reviewed on its release, hell, most get reviewed prior. Every Blizzard expansion for their WoW get's reviewed as is, because when you release something it's supposed to be finished and polished.

5.9/10

90%? You sound pretty certain. I only see negativity here and there. The tileset is from PC and hasnt been touched. However, I have tried to replace it but it is not my final decision to do so. HomelessWitch likes the current tileset and there not much of anything else I can do to change her mind.

As my "power," I have indeed changed a lot of the original images on the server. To this day, there is still a lot more to be fixed and only time can tell when it will be done. So, yes, you are correct about me using my power to do so.
But nothing else can be done about changing the tileset. (Awhile ago iPink and I were revamping the whole thing but HW said she liked the current one.. not sure why.)

Exactly. It is not 'finished' or 'polished' You can give review and discuss what you'll want to implement, and the current bugs - but giving a rating for a game that has only been released since Saturday isn't really helpful.

You obviously didn't understand my post lol. It's SUPPOSED to be finished and polished AT release, not after. First impressions are everything for these servers and if the first impression is not finished or polished, that is how people will keep it in their minds. This server should not have been released yet. Its a cash grab.

Tileset- 8
storyline- 6
quests- quests?
weapons- 8
fun- 5
friendly- 7
events- (havent done any yet)
updates- ??????????

People are never going to understand it's meant to be like Era are they?

and Era is bad, just a huge P2Win MMO

Don't you play WoW?

Use to, but you see, in Wow you pay money to play the game, you can't use money to buy items/levels (unless done illegally) so it isn't Pay2Win it's Pay2Play.

I really hate the graphics, specifically the tiles. I barely played because of just how unappealing the tileset is to look at.

Really? I personally like the tileset.

My feeling when I enter Classic.

However, these are the tiles that were left untouched since Homeless didn't want to replace them just yet. (2005 tiles)

Tileset-0.Fits theme+1,copied from era-2,Extra space-99,the water was very confusing. why does it get slow when you reach different depths? you should be swimming on top of it, not wading through the water on the sandy bottom. and you should be extremely tall to be tall enough to wade through the ocean.
storyline-No story except for those tutorials.
quests-no quests unless you count tutorial as a quest
weapons-overpowered, i constantly lost to people with repeat guns because I chose a ****ty gun i thought would be good. One gun also beats all guns.
fun-5.Its very fun for me, but most Graalians tend to hate it. It gets fun when you find friends and a great guild, but most people are separated trying to get Gralats to buy guns rather than helping others.
friendly-4. i love my guild, but I had refused guild invites, and one of the leaders of one of the major towering guides stalked me making fun of me because i was poor. Constant murderers killed me, they call you a noob or a nub.
events-6. they are fun, and i go to event house whenever they announce that they are doing an event.
updates-3.Bombs look like they are from delteria, but i have no right to judge considering I'm a noob on delteria. Also bombs don't fit into the timeline.