2011 before I was banned and quit for a year

2010 because thats when i started and it was the most fun because i was still discovering everything.

2010 was probably the best in terms of gameplay for myself as I was still starting out, exploring the world and what to do/buy, and there's nothing that compares to that "new game" feel. I got most involved in 2012 during the time Advent V was active. Probably 4/5 of my time online was spent then. Met a bunch of great people in that guild, a few of which I still talk to today.

I'll go with 2012.

I would choose 2010 because there were more things to do and i met friends that i still talk to now

2010 was nice because there were a lot of things that were added and that people loved, and the community was young, fresh and engaging. 2011 was pretty great for me personally because I joined US and met a lot of great new friends starting that year. Although iClassic was first released in mid December 2009, I loved that holiday season and the winter break from school that I spend so many hours playing Graal. The community was so new, and the RPG element was completely built by the community, which was really fun. The initial experience on the game is still a cool memory, and I can't say it wasn't important enough to note because it really was a memorable time of my time playing Graal.

The community is getting worse and worse why in God's name did people vote for 2012+

Voted 2013:

• New tiles so the server actually looks good
• Easter Update
• Halloween is still extremely fun
• Presumably there will be a Christmas just as good as last year's.

2011 was the year snowtown was resleased!